Every June, FCI publishes its Annual Review, giving an overview of progress made by the world's most extensive and important factoring network. The Annual Review presents FCI's annual figures and global factoring statistics. In this extract from the FCI Annual Review 2024, we explore the Regional Updates for Europe, presented by Ms. Betül Kurtulus, FCI Regional Director Central, Eastern and South-Eastern Europe and the Middle East, and Mr. Fausto Galmarini, Chairman of the EUF.
>> Download your free copy of the FCI Annual Review 2024
2023 Figures
CEE, SEE and the Middle East
Although the growth rate of factoring volumes in the Central and Eastern Europe (CEE) and Southeast Europe (SEE) region last year was less robust than the previous year’s expansion, 2023 was still a productive year compared to the region’s economic growth rates. While total transaction volume in the region increased by 25.5% in 2022; it experienced single-digit growth in 2023. Countries such as Romania, Hungary, Slovenia, Croatia, Serbia, Poland, and Turkey led the growth in the CEE and SEE region. By contrast, turnover in the Middle East remained stagnant compared to the previous year. This slowdown can largely be attributed to challenges in obtaining data rather than a decrease in turnover.
European Union
In 2023, the total European Union turnover reached EUR 2.443 billion, an increase of 2%. After two years of double-digit growth, we expected a lower increase due to the negative dynamics of the EU GDP, which dropped to 0.4% from 3.5% in 2022. The ECB’s severe policy to curb inflation led to rapid increases in lending rates, coupled with conflicts between Russia and Ukraine and Israel and Palestine. Despite this, the European factoring market remains the most important globally, representing 66% of the world market. The penetration rate of factoring over European GDP in 2023 was stable at 12%, proving its importance in the European economy. International factoring also remained stable at 22% of the total turnover. Non-recourse factoring (53%) was higher than recourse factoring, as clients sought to cover debtors’ risk. Funding of EUR 304 billion supports around 303,000 European clients, aiding economic development, employment, and business success.
Legal, Regulatory and Advocacy
CEE, SEE and the Middle East
Throughout 2023, FCI remained committed to supporting legal and regulatory reforms to facilitate factoring in the Central and Eastern Europe (CEE), Southeast Europe (SEE), and Middle East regions. We collaborated closely with esteemed partners such as the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development (EBRD) and the International Finance Corporation (IFC) World Bank Group to bolster the infrastructure of these regions. Numerous engagements and developments occurred with regulators and lawmakers in the region, paving the way for advancements in the legal framework governing factoring. Noteworthy progress includes ongoing factoring law studies in Jordan, Uzbekistan, and Ukraine, with active involvement from their central banks, ministries of finance, and investment banks. In 2024, we anticipate enacting regulatory reforms supportive of the factoring sector in these countries. Furthermore, significant strides have been made to enhance the legal infrastructure for government-backed digital solutions. Initiatives are underway to expand the presence of successful invoice registration centres akin to Turkey's model, particularly in Middle Eastern countries. We are witnessing a growing demand for education from these countries' financial sectors and regulators, reflecting a keen interest in fostering sectoral development. These government-supported digital solutions are pivotal in advancing the receivable finance sector. They streamline processes and contribute significantly to the sector's growth and sustainability.
European Union
In 2023, the European Factoring and Commercial Finance industry faced several issues:
- the CSDD directive that requires all businesses to manage their entire operational environmental and social impacts,
- the EBA’s final non-banking lending report, the EU-wide implementation of Basel III/CRR3 (including NDOD),
- the ongoing works on AML/CFT legislative package band the new AMLA,
- digital age VAT, and
- the new directive harmonising aspects of substantive law on insolvency proceedings.
Regarding the CRR Reform/Basel III, the EUF supported the position of the EU Council that doesn’t include factoring in the ancillary services and welcomed the amendments on Article 183 and Article 213 which delete required coverage of frauds that credit protection needs to be eligible for credit risk mitigation. As for the eligibility and use of credit insurance as a CRM technique, EUF welcomed that the EBA and EIOPA work in close cooperation. In regard to the issue of the NDOD, the EU Council invited EBA to consider the need for providing flexibility to institutions. The EU Parliament stated that EBA shall update its default guidelines before June 2024. To find out more about this, read the EUF Summer 2024 Newsletter here.
Promotion and Awareness
CEE, SEE and the Middle East
In 2023, FCI led numerous initiatives in the region, advancing the factoring industry and fostering key stakeholder collaboration, to promote international factoring, reverse factoring, and Islamic international factoring. Our annual CEE conference saw significant attendance from members, observers, and regulators. The success of FCI’s regional gatherings continues to grow each year, encouraging collaboration and knowledge exchange among our expanding membership base. We also hosted workshops at events like the EBRD Annual Meeting in Samarkand and the GTR conference in Riyadh, focusing on best practices in the factoring industry. After the FCI Annual Meeting in Marrakech, we partnered with EBRD to host a joint conference on Factoring and Supply Chain Finance. Additionally, we participated in the EBRD TPF Trade Finance Forum in Vienna. Our commitment to supporting Ukraine remained steadfast, as demonstrated by our involvement in the UATFF Annual Trade Finance Conference. We also engaged in partner events across the region, including in Baku, the UAE, and Uzbekistan. In Istanbul, we had meaningful discussions about our services with both current and prospective FCI members and clients.
European Union
As underlined in the trend of the market, the European Factoring and Commercial Finance market represents more than two-thirds of the world’s global turnover. It is gratifying to see the results of our efforts in supporting effectively the European real economy. We also work to reinforce these key messages with our regulators and lawmakers and to improve the way we provide our services for the benefit of all the stakeholders. In April 2023, EUF and FCI jointly organised the EU Factoring and Commercial Finance Summit in Cologne. It was very successful, thanks also to the participation, among others, of Mr Gaetano Chionsini, Head of Statistics EBA, who gave a snapshot of the lending market and NPL. The programme addressed the latest updates and promoted the impact of the factoring industry in Europe.
Membership Mobilisation
CEE, SEE and the Middle East
In response to the positive developments in the Central and Eastern Europe (CEE), Southeast Europe (SEE), and Middle East regions, FCI welcomed seven new members in 2023. These additions included members from Kosovo, North Macedonia, Romania, Saudi Arabia, Serbia, Georgia, and the UAE.
European Union
EUF has relationships with nearly all national factoring associations and will continue efforts to further expand its membership. To reinforce lobbying with regulators and European authorities, the EUF has established closer cooperation, particularly with Leaseurope and the European Banking Federation (EBF).
Challenges
CEE, SEE and the Middle East
The CEE and SEE regions face numerous challenges from internal and external factors. The economic downturn, worsened by geopolitical tensions like Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, has resulted in higher financial risks, such as exchange rate fluctuations and regulatory hurdles. Corporate insolvencies are rising, and economic growth lags behind potential, with businesses facing higher input costs and lower foreign demand. Despite some signs of consumer-driven recovery, companies in these regions continue to confront pressures from rising commodity and labour costs, creating a challenging business environment in 2024. Germany remains the primary trading partner for most CEE economies, and there are signs of a consumer-driven rebound in daily necessities, supporting economic activity in the CEE region. These conditions suggest a continued need for working capital in the factoring sector. In the Middle East, sustainability is crucial for economic diversification. The region benefits from the global economy’s resilience, facilitated by lower commodity prices and vigilant policy measures to counter inflationary pressures. However, ongoing political risks, shipping disruptions, and lower oil production create uncertainty and uneven recovery across the Middle East and GCC (The Gulf Cooperation Council). While sustainability and green financing are key priorities across all regions, transitioning to these conditions may pose short-term challenges, particularly for Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs). These challenges may affect trade finance and Supply Chain Finance (SCF) transactions, impacting the broader economic landscape. As businesses adapt to sustainability requirements, smaller enterprises may face initial hurdles navigating the complexities of becoming more environmentally friendly.
European Union
Regarding the review of the Late Payment Directive and the introduction of the Late Payment Regulation (LPR), the EUF sent a position paper to the EU Commission highlighting that the 2011 directive has not decreased late payments, especially in the public sector, where public administration debtors are still paying late. The new LPR, which obligates payment within 30 days, will likely increase funding needs (estimated at EUR 150 billion by the European Association of Businesses), necessitating greater SME resilience. Forms of financing like factoring are not part of the problem but rather part of the solution to the late payments issue. Limiting or prohibiting ‘bans on assignments’ would likely increase the availability and use of factoring in the EU. We hope the trilogue will accept our proposal to remove the ban on assignment from supply contracts. The CRR review requires an effort to introduce new elements in the compromise text of the European Parliament and Council of the European Union. In a recent roundtable with EBA, the use of credit insurance as a risk mitigation technique was examined, but we didn’t expect positive feedback because European insurers could not provide data evidence. We believe the best result for EUF is to extend the technical past due from 30 to 90 days, which would significantly reduce automatic defaults, even if not entirely.
Outlook 2024
CEE, SEE and the Middle East
The economic outlook for Europe in 2024 is promising, with a projected rebound in export growth by 2.2%, an improvement from the previous year. This export growth is expected to be accompanied by a recovery in import trade volume, forecasted to increase by 1.6%. Easing interest rates anticipated in 2024, alongside an expected recovery in economic activity and increased demand for European goods, makes the outlook more optimistic. Anticipated improvements in export and import volumes suggest a positive trajectory for the European economy in 2024, aiming for resurgence and stability. A positive factoring market is expected in 2024 for CEE and SEE regions. The Middle East is expected to grow by 2.3% in 2024 as it benefits from favourable commodity prices. The region is also using commodity profits to diversify into new sectors and markets, further driving growth.
European Union
EUF expects slightly better turnover growth in 2024 due to EU GDP recovery and lower interest rates from reduced inflation. Geopolitical conflicts pose challenges. EUF has three main issues. First, NDOD causes many ‘false positive’ errors by classifying buyers as default due to overdue payments. Extending the technical past due from 30 to 90 days could help but requires CRR revision. EUF relies on members to gather needed data to prove factoring's lower risk to EBA. Second, the LPR requires debtors to pay invoices within 30 days. EUF hopes the final draft prohibits or limits assignments, as factoring addresses late payments. Third, CSDD mandates due diligence on corporate environmental and human rights impact. EUF seeks exemption as compliance would be burdensome for the industry. EUF remains committed to protecting the factoring industry and its role in supporting the real economy.
(Photo: © Richard Sharrocks)